New Fairtrade Standard will not benefit garment workers

published 22-03-2016 08:33, last modified 22-03-2016 08:33
Fairtrade International announced to publish its new Fairtrade Textile Standard on 22 March 2016. Clean Clothes Campaign (CCC) raised concerns and gave detailed input during the Standard’s development and remains critical today. In order to improve working conditions, a sector-wide approach is needed and corporate behavior has to change, not only some selected supply chains.

The CCCs main concerns include:

1. Product label approach is not the right tool for this industry

The Fairtrade Textile Standard, as a product label-approach, is limited to individual selected supply chains of the company and does not cover its entire business activities. Working for more than 25 years in this area, Clean Clothes Campaign believes that the existing problems in the industry can only be solved if companies change comprehensively their corporate behavior and if there is a sector-wide approach to tackle underlying root causes that lead to labour and human rights violations. The standard does not sufficiently address the challenges in the garment industry and even risks slowing down progress made in the last few years. A product label approach is problematic because it allows brands to pick and choose and to create one “fairtrade” product in one supply chain while carrying on with business as usual in all other supply chains.

2. The Standard diverts responsibility away from brands

The new Fairtrade Textile Standard is quite comprehensive, but it does not hold brands responsible for respecting decent labour conditions, and it does not guarantee that all workers involved in making a brand`s products are paid a living wage. The Standard includes complex and costly requirements for factories, but does not require brands to commit to real change in terms of their purchasing and operating practices.

3. A Standard relying on inspections and certification is dangerous

Crucial for any standard are its delivery and assessment mechanisms. Fairtrade International bases its assessment almost entirely on social auditing, even though this has been repeatedly proven not to adequately assess workplace practices, let alone to trigger systemic change. CCC sees little elements that suggest that the standard would bring more concrete results than other existing social standards. Fairtrade International wants to implement the Standard with support programs. In order to really have influence and tackle the far-reaching challenges, a big and long-term effort is needed. It remains unclear how such programs would be financed in the long run.

4. Marking garments as “fairtrade” without paying a living wage is unacceptable and misleads consumers

The Fairtrade Textile Standard allows an implementation period of six years for a living wage. The standard foresees that the factory management has to sign an implementation plan with workers representatives, but the factory has no guarantee that the buyers stay as prices go up. If the burden of implementing a living wage lies entirely on the supplier, CCC fears that no factory management will commit to such a plan. Brands need to play a central role in reaching a living wage. Marking garments as 'fairtrade' before a living wage has actually been paid to the workers is unacceptable for CCC. It is misleading for consumers and allows for disproportionate marketing benefits for brands.

See also
Open letter: After five years, it is high time to pay severance to 345 workers who made adidas and Mizuno shoes Open letter: After five years, it is high time to pay severance to 345 workers who made adidas and Mizuno shoes

Today five years ago, a group of Indonesian workers started a strike after their employer had ...

European Parliament should vote for an investigation into Bangladesh labour violations European Parliament should vote for an investigation into Bangladesh labour violations

Clean Clothes Campaign is today calling on members of the European Parliament to call for a trade ...

Old design are dinner better nearer silent excuse Old design are dinner better nearer silent excuse

On 24 April 2017 the Clean Clothes Campaign network will be remembering those killed and injured at ...

Pressure mounting for UNIQLO to pay Indonesian workers compensation Pressure mounting for UNIQLO to pay Indonesian workers compensation

Following the actions on International Women's Day in Hong Kong, two Indonesian unions protested at ...

CCC urge EU to address Sri Lanka's labour violations prior to re-admission GSP+ CCC urge EU to address Sri Lanka's labour violations prior to re-admission GSP+

Clean Clothes Campaign, IndustriALL Global Union and the International Trade Union Confederation ...

Labour rights groups call for a review of EU-Bangladesh trade agreement following massive crackdown on workers rights

The Clean Clothes Campaign is today joining calls from the global trade unions to demand that the ...

Brands must intervene to win release of imprisoned labour leaders in Bangladesh

Twenty-two human and labour rights organizations from around the world are calling on H&M, C&A, ...

Bangladeshi garment workers face mass firings and criminal charges

Since last month's wage protests began in Dhaka, Bangladesh thousands of workers along with several ...

CCC condemns escalating repression of unionists amid wage strikes Bangladesh

Clean Clothes Campaign (CCC) is today raising concerns about the safety of trade union leaders and ...

Free the Tipitapa 12: Nicaraguan workers prosecuted after peaceful protest Free the Tipitapa 12: Nicaraguan workers prosecuted after peaceful protest

Last Friday 16th December the twelve workers accused as a consequence of the riot police ...

more ...